The idea towards placement (besides construction a hostage)

During the 1228, it appears that which same Clemence along with her partner Nicholas had been picked for custody off Joanna and you may Llywelyn's child Susanna (aged about fourteen?). is apparently to your child to-be raised from inside the a safe and you will safer environment towards chance of a better training. the truth was in fact getting remaining of her. This new custodial give is actually by the Queen Henry III, half-sis in order to Joanna and you may 50 % of-cousin to Susanna, the decree named Susanna, Henry's ‘niece' and you will Joanna, Henry's ‘sister'.'

A concern today presents in itself. You to definitely you'll response is you to definitely Clemence's dad, Philip le Boteler is French, in place of English. It actually was common at the time for all those to hang features into the both parties of Channel. This ed his dilies compared to English parents during this time.

The sole guide where I've encountered a mention of Clemence Pinel – partner off Henry Pinel (apart from Charles Cawley within the Wikipedia) is within Alison Weir's ‘England's Royal Parents: The complete Genealogy (London, 1989).' It guide try noted of the one to genealogist given that ‘not as fully annotated.' My very own trawl through the genealogy discussion boards located scant reference towards Pinel relatives, along with Clemence's spouse Henry Pinel. Numerous records suggest that Joanna is the new child off Henry Pinel with his partner Clemence, but no source, capable of being featured, are given. I am therefore tempted to dismiss this lady regarding next analysis. I am able to feel really incorrect.

In the event that Joanna is the child of Clemence ce Boteler, of, appear to an enthusiastic English family, how do we define just what Joanna is starting for the France whenever Queen John delivered to possess their into the 1203?

Clemence de Fougers try the newest sibling off Richard de- Hommet, Constable regarding Normandy, and Geoffrey de- Fougeres. Their father is William du Fougers. You will find no big date out-of delivery (otherwise dying) away from Clemence, however, she was hitched prior to 1200 (no big date readily available) to help you Alan de Dinan, and is prominent sufficient to marry in October 1200, since the their own second husband, Ranulph de- Blundeville, Earl from Chester and you may Vicomte d'Avranches, recently divorced (relationship annulled?) of Constance off hot american girl Brittany.

In 1189, aged seventeen, Ranulph had been married to Constance of Brittany the widow of Henry 11 ‘s son Geoffrey, and the mother of Arthur of Brittany with whom King John contested the succession. Henry did not trust the Countess and wanted her married to a magnate he could trust. The marriage gave Ranulph control of the earldom of Richmond and the duchy of Brittany, but it was not a success (see subject 6. below). The couple had no issue and they separated. It was rumoured you to Earl Ranulph separated Constance in order to have got an affair that have King John!

Definitely, carry out this Clemence be the mom from Joanna, she’d be also the newest granny away from Susanna, although there isn’t any need to trust that the young Joanna understood, at this time, there is actually children dating, if

Given that Clemence de Fougers try child and you will aunt out of Constables of Normandy, It is think likely that John, Number away from Mortain, during the Normandy, knew out-of their own [and possibly *knew* their particular, in advance of their unique relationship so you're able to Ranulph]. A near connection to John you will define what would see an extremely useful second wedding to have Clemence to Ranulph.

Ranulph, 6 th Earl regarding Chester not, is a strong baron therefore beggars belief, at least personally, which he might have approved a marriage in order to a female exactly who had had a known affair and you can a following youngster from the John, Amount out-of Mortain certain a decade in the past. Including because of the rumours related a potential fling between John and you can 1st wife Constance!